>

Martyred for the Gospel

Martyred for the Gospel
The burning of Tharchbishop of Cant. D. Tho. Cranmer in the town dich at Oxford, with his hand first thrust into the fyre, wherwith he subscribed before. [Click on the picture to see Cranmer's last words.]

Daily Bible Verse

Showing posts with label common grace. Show all posts
Showing posts with label common grace. Show all posts

Saturday, June 06, 2026

The 2026 Edition of the PRCA Theological Journal: Common Grace

 

Recommended Article:  "John Bolt, Common Grace, the PRCA, and Theological Modernism"

 by David J. Engelsma

Protestant Reformed Theological Journal.  Vol. 59, No. 2., 2026.  Pp. 49-65.


Reviewed by Charlie J. Ray


In a time when supposedly Evangelical and Reformed denominations are compromised with the pragmatic church growth movement and other theological heresies, Dr. David J. Engelsma's article is a breath of fresh air.  The Presbyterian Church in America, the Associate Reformed Presbyterian Church, and the Orthodox Presbyterian Church are the Presbyterian denominations with which I am most familiar because I grew up in Florida, and now I live in South Carolina.  All of these denominations downplay their doctrinal standards because they wish to be evangelistic and mission minded.  While the PCA does not ordain women to the church offices of teaching elder or deacon, there is no vow taken for membership that even mentions the Westminster Standards.  The ARP ordains women deacons in violation of 1 Timothy 3:8-12 KJV.   (See:  Reasonable Christian:  Should Women Be Ordained to the Office of Deacon?)

The ARP First Presbyterian Church in Columbia, South Carolina has had three Reformed ministers from the supposedly conservative Ligonier Ministries movement of the late Dr. R.C. Sproul.  Yet, all three agreed with the session to ordain women to the male only office of deacon.  The present minister is Dr. Neil Stewart, who told me that if I objected to women deacons that I should probably not join as a member.  The other two pastors were Derek Thomas and Sinclaire Ferguson.

Moreover, the dangers of the pragmatic church growth movement are that the emphasis is on keeping the peace and unity at the cost of doctrinal purity and true Christian discipleship.  As Dr. Engelsma points out in this article, it all began with the adoption of the Three Points of Common Grace in 1924 by the Christian Reformed Church.  Practically all of the Presbyterian denominations quickly unofficially adopted the Three Points of Common Grace because the colleges and seminaries teach this doctrine as if it were an official doctrinal standard.  The doctrine then trickled down to the denominations and churches.  (See my open letter to the pastor of an ARP church plant in Lexington, South Carolina:  Lexington ARP.  The response I got from Jeff Tell by email was short and to the point:  I hope you can find a perfect church.)

Theological modernism shows up most clearly in the rejection of doctrinal standards and in the adoption of modern translations of the Bible that are based on the liberal biases of lower and higher biblical criticism.  Dr. Engelsma mentions that modernism began in the CRC before the ministers of the PRCA were expelled from the CRC.  At least one seminary professor at Calvin Theological Seminary, Ralph Janssen, who taught Old Testament, was expelled for teaching that the Pentateuch was not historical narrative.  Janssen taught what could be called a neo-orthodox view of Genesis 1-11, a view that is popular among fake Evangelicals today.

The failure of theological liberalism to see that humanity is not good was clearly visible during the first world war.  Apparently, the liberals doubled down.  The following quote from Engelsma's articles is pertinent to this point:

In 1924, the attack of modernism upon Christian orthodoxy was raging. The highly regarded and influential German heretic, von Harnack, published his popular attack on orthodox Christianity in 1900, Das Wesen des Christentums (What is Christianity?). In 1903, the Presbyterian Church (USA) revised the Westminster Confession of Faith to affirm a love of God for all humans. The unbelieving, modernistic Auburn Affirmation was published in 1924—in 1924! Harry Emerson Fosdick preached his popular sermon, “Shall the Fundamentalists Win?” in 1922. 

And the CRC itself wrestled with sheer modernism in the Janssen case, Calvin Seminary Professor Ralph Janssen being deposed in 1922. 

In the ecclesiastical atmosphere of this theological and spiritual struggle, the CRC adopted the doctrine of common grace, affirming a oneness of the church and the world in a common grace of God.  (Engelsma, pp. 62-63).

The current controversy over the issue of lower textual criticism and the reasoned eclecticism of the approach to textual variants and fragmentary apographs of the Greek New Testament is related to this compromise with common grace as well.  Unfortunately, the modern science of textual criticism is a dismal failure in regard to the stated goal of objectively reconstructing the precise wording of the original autographs.  (See:  Reformation Bible Society).

I highly recommend this article if you are at all concerned with the theological modernism and liberalism that is creeping into Evangelical churches today.  Even more concerning is the leftward drift of the Reformed churches due to the heresy of common grace:

From the Netherlands, the infection of modernism in the form of a common grace uniting church and world has spread to the CRC. It threatens all the supposedly “conservative” Reformed and Presbyterian churches that have been influenced by Kuyper and the CRC to embrace the doctrine of a common grace of God. They have the essence of modernism at their vitals. This is, in reality, the issue for the churches of NAPARC, not the issue of women in church office, which is merely a symptom of the real issue, and not the most important, but the issue of common grace, which obliterates the antithesis between church and world.  (Engelsma, p. 63).

You can read Dr. David Engelsma's article by clicking here:  Protestant Reformed Theological Journal, Vol. 59, 2026.  Then click the download button to download and read the PDF version of the journal.  Dr. Engelsma's article is on pages 49-65.

The peace of God be with you. 

Sunday, April 26, 2026

The Declaration of Principles of the Protestant Reformed Churches in America

A brief Exposition of the Confessions Regarding Certain Points of Doctrine as Maintained by the Protestant Reformed Churches


Adopted by the Synod of 1951


Preamble

DECLARATION OF PRINCIPLES, to be used only by the Mission Committee and the missionaries for the organization of prospective churches on the basis of Scripture and the Confessions as these have always been maintained in the Protestant Reformed Churches and as these are now further explained in regard to certain principles.


The Protestant Reformed Churches stand on the basis of Scripture as the infallible Word of God and of the Three Forms of Unity. Moreover, they accept the liturgical forms used in the public worship of our churches, such as:


Form for the Administration of Baptism, Form for the Administration of the Lord's Supper, Form of Excommunication, Form of Readmitting Excommunicated Persons, Form of Ordination of the Ministers of God's Word, Form of Ordination of elders and Deacons, Form for the Installation of Professors of Theology, Form of Ordination of Missionaries, Form for the Confirmation of Marriage before the Church, and the Formula of Subscription.


On the basis of this Word of God and these confessions:


I. They repudiate the errors of the Three Points adopted by the Synod of the Christian Reformed Church of Kalamazoo, 1924, which maintain:

A. That there is a grace of God to all men, including the reprobate, manifest in the common gifts to all men.


B. That the preaching of the gospel is a gracious offer of salvation on the part of God to all that externally hear the gospel.


C. That the natural man through the influence of common grace can do good in this world.


D. Over against this they maintain:


1. That the grace of God is always particular, i.e., only for the elect, never for the reprobate.


2. That the preaching of the gospel is not a gracious offer of salvation on the part of God to all men, nor a conditional offer to all that are born in the historical dispensation of the covenant, that is, to all that are baptized, but an oath of God that He will infallibly lead all the elect unto salvation and eternal glory through faith.


3. That the unregenerate man is totally incapable of doing any good, wholly depraved, and therefore can only sin.


For proof, we refer to Canons I,A.,6-8:


Art. 6. That some receive the gift of faith from God, and others do not receive it proceeds from God's eternal decree, "for known unto God are all his works from the beginning of the world," Acts 15:18. "Who worketh all things after the counsel of his will," Eph. 111. According to which decree, he graciously softens the hearts of the elect, however obstinate, and inclines them to believe, while he leaves the non-elect in his judgment to their own wickedness and obduracy. And herein is especially displayed the profound, the merciful, and at the same time the righteous discrimination between men, equally involved in ruin; or that decree of election and reprobation, revealed in the Word of God, which though men of perverse, impure and unstable minds wrest to their own destruction, yet to holy and pious souls affords unspeakable consolation.


Art. 7. Election is the unchangeable purpose of God, whereby, before the foundation of the world, he hath out of mere grace, according to the sovereign good pleasure of his own will, chosen, from the whole human race, which had fallen through their own fault, from their primitive state of rectitude, into sin and destruction, a certain number of persons to redemption in Christ, whom he from eternity appointed the Mediator and Head of the elect, and the foundation of salvation.


This elect number, though by nature neither better nor more deserving than others, but with them involved in one common misery, God hath decreed to give to Christ, to be saved by him, and effectually to call and draw them to his communion by his Word and Spirit, to bestow upon them true faith, justification and sanctification and having powerfully preserved them in the fellowship of his Son, finally, to glorify them for the demonstration of his mercy, and for the praise of his glorious grace; as it is written, "According as he hath chosen us in him, before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy, and without blame before him in love; having predestinated us unto the adoption of children by Jesus Christ to himself, according to the good pleasure of his will, to the praise of the glory of his grace, wherein he hath made us accepted in the beloved," Eph. 1:4,5, 6. And elsewhere: "Whom he did predestinate, them he also called, and whom he called, them he also justified, and whom he justified, them he also glorified." Rom. 8:30.


Art. 8. There are not various decrees of election, but one and the same decree respecting all those, who shall be saved, both under the Old and New Testament: since the Scripture declares the good pleasure, purpose and counsel of the divine will to be one, according to which he hath chosen us from eternity, both to grace and glory, to salvation and the way of salvation, which he hath ordained that we should walk therein.


Canons II,A,5:


Art. 5, Moreover, the promise of the gospel is, that whosoever believeth in Christ crucified, shall not perish, but have everlasting life. This promise, together with the command to repent and believe, ought to be declared and published to all nations, and to all persons promiscuously and without distinction, to whom God out of his good pleasure sends the gospel.


The Canons in II, 5 speak of the preaching of the promise. It presents the promise, not as general, but as particular, i.e., as for believers, and, therefore, for the elect. This preaching of the particular promise is promiscuous to all that hear the gospel with the command, not a condition, to repent and believe.


Canons II,B,6:


Art. 6. Who use the difference between meriting and appropriating, to the end that they may instill into the minds of the imprudent and inexperienced this teaching that God, as far as he is concerned, has been minded of applying to all equally the benefits gained by the death of Christ; but that while some obtain the pardon of sin and eternal life, and others do not, this difference depends on their own free will, which joins itself to the grace that is offered without exception, and that it is not dependent on the special gift of mercy, which powerfully works in them, that they rather than others should appropriate unto themselves this grace. For these, while they feign that they present this distinction, in a sound sense, seek to instill into the people the destructive poison of the Pelagian errors.


For further proof we refer to the Heidelberg Catechism, III,8, and XXXIII, 91:


Q. 8. Are we then so corrupt that we are wholly incapable of doing any good, and inclined to all wickedness?


A. Indeed we are; except we are regenerated by the Spirit of God.


Q. 91. But what are good works?


A. Only those which proceed from a true faith, are performed according to the law of God, and to his glory; and not such as are founded on our imaginations, or the institutions of men.


And also from the Netherlands Confession, Article XIV:


Art. XIV. We believe that God created man out of the dust of the earth, and made and formed him after his own image and likeness, good, righteous, and holy, capable in all things to will, agreeably to the will of God. But being in honor, he understood it not, neither knew his excellency, but willfully subjected himself to sin, and consequently to death, and the curse, giving ear to the words of the devil. For the commandment of life, which he had received, he transgressed; and by sin separated himself from God, who was his true life, having corrupted his whole nature; whereby he made himself liable to corporal and spiritual death. And being thus become wicked, perverse, and corrupt in all his ways, he hath lost all his excellent gifts, which he had received from God, and only retained a few remains thereof, which, however, are sufficient to leave man without excuse; for all the light which is in us is changed into darkness, as the Scriptures teach us, saying: The light shineth in darkness, and the darkness comprehendeth it not: where St. John calleth men darkness. Therefore we reject all that is taught repugnant to this, concerning the free will of man, since man is but a slave to sin; and has nothing of himself, unless it is given from heaven. For who may presume to boast, that he of himself can do any good, since Christ saith, No man can come to me, except the Father, which hath sent me, draw him? Who will glory in his own will, who understands, that to be carnally minded is enmity against God? Who can speak of his knowledge, since the natural man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God? In short, who dare suggest any thought, since he knows that we are not sufficient of ourselves to think anything as of ourselves, but that our sufficiency is of God? And therefore what the apostle saith ought justly to be held sure and firm that God worketh in us both to will and to do of his good pleasure. For there is no will nor understanding, conformable to the divine will and understanding, but what Christ hath wrought in man; which he teaches us, when he saith, Without me ye can do nothing.


Once more we refer to Canons III-IV, A, 1-4:


Art. 1. Man was originally formed after the image of God, His understanding was adorned with a true and saving knowledge of his Creator, and of spiritual things; his heart and will were upright; all his affections pure; and the whole man was holy; but revolting from God by the instigation of the devil, and abusing the freedom of his own will, he forfeited these excellent gifts; and on the contrary entailed on himself blindness of mind, horrible darkness, vanity and perverseness of judgment, became wicked, rebellious, and obdurate in heart and will, and impure in his affections.


Art. 2. Man after the fall begat children in his own likeness. A corrupt stock produced a corrupt off-spring. Hence all the posterity of Adam, Christ only excepted, have derived corruption from their original parent, not by imitation, as the Pelagians of old asserted, but by the propagation of a vicious nature.


Art. 3. Therefore all men are conceived in sin, and by nature children of wrath, incapable of saving good, prone to evil, dead in sin, and in bondage thereto, and without the regenerating grace of the Holy Spirit, they are neither able nor willing to return to God, to reform the depravity of their nature, nor to dispose themselves to reformation.


Art. 4. There remain, however, in man since the fall the glimmerings of natural light, whereby he retains some knowledge of God, of natural things, and of the differences between good and evil, and discovers some regard for virtue, good order in society, and for maintaining an orderly external deportment. But so far is this light of nature from being sufficient to bring him to a saving knowledge of God, and to true conversion, that he is incapable of using it aright even in things natural and civil. Nay further, this light, such as it is, man in various ways renders wholly polluted, and holds it in unrighteousness, by doing which he becomes inexcusable before God.


II. They teach on the basis of the same confessions:

A. That election, which is the unconditional and unchangeable decree of God to redeem in Christ a certain number of persons, is the sole cause and fountain of all our salvation, whence flow all the gifts of grace, including faith. This is the plain teaching of our confessions in the Canons of Dordrecht, I,A,6,7. See above.


And in the Heidelberg Catechism XXI, 54, we read:


Q. 54. What believest thou concerning the "holy catholic church" of Christ?


A. That the Son of God from the beginning to the end of the world, gathers, defends, and preserves to himself by his Spirit and Word, out of the whole human race, a church chosen to everlasting life, agreeing in true faith; and that I am and forever shall remain a living member thereof.


This is also evident from the doctrinal part of the Form for the Administration of Baptism, where we read:


For when we are baptized in the name of the Father, God the Father witnesseth and sealeth unto us that he doth make an eternal covenant of grace with us, and adopts us for his children and heirs, and therefore will provide us with every good thing, and avert all evil or turn it to our profit. And when we are baptized in the name of the Son, the son sealeth unto us, that he doth wash us in his blood from all our sins, incorporating us into the fellowship of his death and resurrection, so that we are freed from all our sins, and accounted righteous before God. In like manner, when we are baptized in the name of the Holy Ghost, the Holy Ghost assures us, by this holy sacrament, that he will dwell in us, and sanctify us to be members of Christ, applying unto us, that which we have in Christ, namely, the washing away of our sins, and the daily renewing of our lives, till we shall finally be presented without spot or wrinkle among the assembly of the elect in life eternal.


B. That Christ died only for the elect and that the saving efficacy of the death of Christ extends to them only.


This is evident from the Canons, II,A,8:


Art. 8. For this was the sovereign counsel, and most gracious will and purpose of God the Father, that the quickening and saving efficacy of the most precious death of his Son should extend to all the elect, for bestowing upon them alone the gift of justifying faith, thereby to bring them infallibly to salvation: that is, it was the will of God, that Christ by the blood of the cross, whereby he confirmed the new covenant, should effectually redeem out of every people, tribe, nation, and language, all those, and those only, who were from eternity chosen to salvation, and given to him by the Father; that he should confer upon them faith, which together with all the other saving gifts of the Holy Spirit, he purchased for them by his death; should purge them from all sin, both original and actual, whether committed before or after believing; and having faithfully preserved them even to the end, should at last bring them free from every spot and blemish to the enjoyment of glory in his own presence forever.


This article very clearly teaches:


1. That all the covenant blessings are for the elect alone.


2. That God's promise is unconditionally for them only: for God cannot promise what was not objectively permitted by Christ.


3. That the promise of God bestows the objective right of salvation not upon all the children that are born under the historical dispensation of the covenant, that is, not upon all that are baptized, but only upon the spiritual seed.


This is also evident from other parts of our confessions, as, for instance:


Heidelberg Catechism XXV, 65-66:


Q. 65. Since then we are made partakers of Christ and all his benefits by faith only, whence doth this faith proceed?


A. From the Holy Ghost, who works faith in our hearts by the preaching of the gospel, and confirms it by the use of the sacraments.


Q. 66. What are the sacraments?


A. The sacraments are holy visible signs and seals, appointed of God for this end, that by the use thereof, he may the more fully declare and seal to us the promise of the gospel, viz., that he grants us freely the remission of sin, and life eternal, for the sake of that one sacrifice of Christ, accomplished on the cross.


If we compare with these statements from the Heidelberger what was taught concerning the saving efficacy of the death of Christ in Canons II,A,8, it is evident that the promise of the gospel which is sealed by the sacraments concerns only the believers, that is, the elect.


This is also evident from the Heidelberg Catechism XXVII, 74,


Q. 74. Are infants also to be baptized?


A. Yes: for since they, as well as the adult, are included in the covenant and church of God; and since redemption from sin by the blood of Christ, and the Holy Ghost, the author of faith, is promised to them no less than to the adult; they must therefore by baptism, as a sign of the covenant, be also admitted into the Christian church; and be distinguished from the children of unbelievers as was done in the old covenant or testament by circumcision, instead of which baptism is instituted in the new covenant.


That in this question and answer of the Heidelberger not all the children that are baptized, but only the spiritual children, that is, the elect, are meant is evident. For:


a. Little infants surely cannot fulfill any conditions. And if the promise of God is for them, the promise is infallible and unconditional, and therefore only for the elect.


b. According to Canons II,A,8, which we quoted above, the saving efficacy of the death of Christ is for the elect alone.


c. According to this answer of the Heidelberg Catechism, the Holy Ghost, the author of faith, is promised to the little children no less than to the adult. And God surely fulfills His promise. Hence, that promise is surely only for the elect.


The same is taught in the Netherlands Confession, Articles XXXIII-XXXV. In Article XXXIII we read:


Art. XXXIII. We believe, that our gracious God, on account of our weakness and infirmities hath ordained the sacraments for us, thereby to seal unto us his promises, and to be pledges of the good will and grace of God toward us, and also to nourish and strengthen our faith; which he hath joined to the Word of the gospel, the better to present to our senses, both that which he signifies to us by his Word, and that which he works inwardly in our hearts, thereby assuring and confirming in us the salvation which he imparts to us. For they are visible signs and seals of an inward and invisible thing, by means whereof God worketh in us by the power of the Holy Ghost. Therefore the signs are not in vain or insignificant, so as to deceive us. For Jesus Christ is the true object presented by them, without whom they would be of no moment.


And from article XXXIV, which speaks of holy baptism, we quote:


Art. XXXIV. We believe and confess that Jesus Christ, who is the end of the law, hath made an end, by the shedding of his blood, of all other sheddings of blood which men could or would make as a propitiation or satisfaction for sin: and that he, having abolished circumcision, which was done with blood, hath instituted the sacrament of baptism instead thereof; by which we are received into the Church of God, and separated from all other people and strange religions, that we may wholly belong to him, whose ensign and banner we bear: and which serves as a testimony to us, that he will forever be our gracious God and Father. Therefore he has commanded all those, who are his, to be baptized with pure water, "in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost"; thereby signifying to us that as water washeth away the filth of the body, when poured upon it, and is seen on the body of the baptized, when sprinkled upon him; so doth the blood of Christ, by the power of the Holy Ghost, internally sprinkle the soul, cleanse it from its sins, and regenerate us from children of wrath, unto children of God. Not that this is effected by the external water, but by the sprinkling of the precious blood of the Son of God; who is our Red Sea, through which we must pass, to escape the tyranny of Pharaoh, that is, the devil, and to enter into the spiritual land of Canaan. Therefore the ministers, on their part, administer the sacrament, and that which is visible, but our Lord giveth that which is signified by the sacrament, namely, the gifts and invisible grace; washing, cleansing and purging our souls of all filth and unrighteousness; renewing our hearts, and filling them with all comfort; giving unto us a true assurance of his fatherly goodness; putting on us the new man, and putting off the old man with all his deeds.


Article XXXIV speaks of holy baptism. That all this, washing and cleansing and purging our souls of all filth and unrighteousness, that renewal of our hearts, is only the fruit of the saving efficacy of the death of Christ and therefore is only for the elect is very evident. The same is true of what we read in the same article concerning the baptism of infants:


Art. XXXIV. And indeed Christ shed his blood no less for the washing of the children of the faithful, than for adult persons; and therefore they ought to receive the sign and sacrament of that, which Christ hath done for them; as the Lord commanded in the law, that they should be made partakers of the sacrament of Christ's suffering and death, shortly after they were born, by offering for them a lamb, which was a sacrament of Jesus Christ. Moreover, what circumcision was to the Jews, that baptism is to our children. And for this reason Paul calls baptism the circumcision of Christ.


If, according to Article 8 of the Second Head of Doctrine, A, in the Canons, the saving efficacy of the death of Christ extends only to the elect, it follows that when in this article of the Netherlands Confession it is stated that "Christ shed his blood no less for the washing of the children of the faithful than for the adult persons," also here the reference is only to the elect children.


Moreover, that the promise of the gospel which God signifies and seals in the sacraments is not for all is also abundantly evident from Article XXXV of the same Netherlands Confession, which speaks of the holy supper of our Lord Jesus Christ. For there we read:


Art. XXXV. We believe and confess, that our Savior Jesus Christ did ordain and institute the sacrament of the holy supper, to nourish and support those whom he hath already regenerated, and incorporated into his family, which is his Church.


In the same article we read:


Further, though the sacraments are connected with the thing signified, nevertheless both are not received by all men; the ungodly indeed receives the sacrament to his condemnation, but he doth not receive the truth of the sacrament. As Judas, and Simon the sorcerer, both indeed received the sacrament, but not Christ, who was signified by it, of whom believers only are made partakers.


It follows from this that both the sacraments, as well as the preaching of the gospel, are a savor of death unto death for the reprobate, as well as a savor of life unto life for the elect. Hence, the promise of God, preached by the gospel, signified and sealed in both the sacraments, is not for all but for the elect only.


And that the election of God, and consequently the efficacy of the death of Christ and the promise of the gospel, is not conditional is abundantly evident from the following articles of the Canons.


Canons I, A, 10:


Art. 10. the good pleasure of God is the sole cause of this gracious election; which doth not consist herein, that out of all possible qualities and actions of men God has chosen some as a condition of salvation; but that he was pleased out of the common mass of sinners to adopt some certain persons as a peculiar people to himself, as it is written, "For the children being not yet born neither having done any good or evil," etc., it was said (namely to Rebecca): "the elder shall serve the younger; as it is written, Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I hated." Romans 9:11-13. "And as many as were ordained to eternal life believed." Acts 13:48.


In Canons I, B, 2, the errors are repudiated of those who teach:


Art. 2. That there are various kinds of election of God unto eternal life: the one general and indefinite, the other particular and definite; and that the latter in turn is either incomplete, revocable, non-decisive and conditional, or complete, irrevocable, decisive and absolute....


And in the same chapter of Canons I, B, 3, the errors are repudiated of those who teach:


Art. 3. That the good pleasure and purpose of God, of which Scripture makes mention in the doctrine of election, does not consist in this, that God chose certain persons rather than others, but in this that he chose out of all possible conditions among which are also the works of the law), or out of the whole order of things, the act of faith, which from its very nature is undeserving, as well as its incomplete obedience, as a condition of salvation, and that he would graciously consider this initself as a complete obedience and count it worthy of the reward of eternal life….


And in the same chapter of Canons I, B, 5, the errors are repudiated of those who teach that:


Art. 5. ...faith, the obedience of faith, holiness, godliness and perseverance are not fruits of the unchangeable election unto glory, but are conditions, which, being required beforehand, were foreseen as being met by those who will be fully elected, and are causes without which the unchangeable election to glory does not occur.


Finally, we refer to the statement of the Baptism Form:


And although our young children do not understand these things, we may not therefore exclude them from baptism, for as they are without their knowledge, partakers of the condemnation in Adam, so are they again received unto grace in Christ....


That here none other than the elect children of the covenant are meant and that they are unconditionally, without their knowledge, received unto grace in Christ, in the same way as they are under the condemnation of Adam, is very evident.


C. That faith is not a prerequisite or condition unto salvation, but a gift of God, and a God-given instrument whereby we appropriate the salvation in Christ. This is plainly taught in the following parts of our confessions:


Heidelberg Catechism VII, 20:


Q. 20. Are all men, then, as they perished in Adam, saved by Christ?


A. No; only those who are engrafted into him, and receive all his benefits, by a true faith.


Netherlands Confession, Article XXII:


Art. XXII. We believe that, to attain the true knowledge of this great mystery, the Holy Ghost kindleth in our hearts an upright faith, which embraces Jesus Christ, with all his merits, appropriates him, and seeks nothing more besides him. For it must needs follow, either that all things, which are requisite to our salvation, are not in Jesus Christ, or if all things are in him, that then those who possess Jesus Christ through faith, have complete salvation in him. Therefore, for any to assert, that Christ is not sufficient, but that something more is required besides him, would be too gross a blasphemy; for hence it would follow, that Christ was but half a Savior. Therefore we justly say with Paul, that we are justified by faith alone, or by faith without works. However, to speak more clearly, we do not mean, that faith itself justifies us, for it is only an instrument with which we embrace Christ our Righteousness. But Jesus Christ, imputing to us all his merits, and so many holy works which he has done for us, and in our stead, is our Righteousness. And faith is an instrument that keeps us in communion with him in all his benefits, which, when become ours, are more than sufficient to acquit us of our sins.


Confer also Netherlands Confession, Articles XXXIII-XXXV, quoted above.


Again, confer Canons of Dordrecht II, A, 8, quoted above.


In Canons III-IV, A, 10, 14 we read:


Art. 10. but that others who are called by the gospel, obey the call, and are converted, is not to be ascribed to the proper exercise of free will, whereby one distinguishes himself above others, equally furnished with grace sufficient for faith and conversions, as the proud heresy of Pelagius maintains; but it must be wholly ascribed to God who as he has chosen his own from eternity in Christ, so he confers upon them faith and repentance, rescues them from the power of darkness, and translates them into the kingdom of his own Son, that they may show forth the praises of him, who hath called them out of darkness into his marvelous light; and may glory not in themselves, but in the Lord according to the testimony of the apostles in various places.


Again, in the same chapter of Canons, Article 14, we read:


Art. 14. Faith is therefore to be considered as the gift of God, not on account of its being offered by God to man, to be accepted or rejected at his pleasure; but because it is in reality conferred, breathed, and infused into him; or even because God bestows the power or ability to believe, and then expects that man should by the exercise of his own free will, consent to the terms of salvation, and actually believe in Christ; but because he who works in man both to will and to do, and indeed all things in all, produces both the will to believe, and the act of believing also.


III. Seeing then that this is the clear teaching of our confession,

A. We repudiate:


1. The teaching:


a. That the promise of the covenant is conditional and for all that are baptized.


b. That we may presuppose that all the children that are baptized are regenerated, for we know on the basis of Scripture, as well as in the light of all history and experience, that the contrary is true.


For proof we refer to Canons I, A, 6-8; and the doctrinal part of the Baptismal Form:


The principal parts of the doctrine of holy baptism are these three:


First, That we with our children are conceived and born in sin, and therefore are children of wrath, in so much that we cannot enter into the kingdom of God, except we are born again. This, the dipping in, or sprinkling with water teaches us, whereby the impurity of our souls is signified, and we admonished to loathe, and humble ourselves before God, and seek for our purification and salvation without ourselves.


Secondly, Holy baptism witnesseth and sealeth unto us the washing away of our sins through Jesus Christ. Therefore we are baptized in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. For when we are baptized in the name of the Father, God the Father witnesseth and sealeth unto us, that he doth make an eternal covenant of grace with us, and adopts us for his children and heirs, and therefore will provide us with every good thing, and avert all evil or turn it to our profit. And when we are baptized in the name of the Son, the Son sealeth unto us, that he doth wash us in his blood from all our sins, incorporating us into the fellowship of his death and resurrection, so that we are freed from all our sins, and accounted righteous before God. In like manner, when we are baptized in the name of the Holy Ghost, the Holy Ghost assures us, by this holy sacrament, that he will dwell in us, and sanctify us to be members of Christ, applying unto us, that which we have in Christ, namely, the washing away of our sins, and the daily renewing of our lives, till we shall finally be presented without spot or wrinkle among the assembly of the elect in life eternal.


Thirdly, Whereas in all covenants, there are contained two parts: therefore are we by God through baptism, admonished of, and obliged unto new obedience, namely, that we cleave to this one God, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost; that we trust in him, and love him with all our hearts, with all our souls, with all our mind, and with all our strength; that we forsake the world, crucify our old nature, and walk in a new and holy life.


And if we sometimes through weakness fall into sin, we must not therefore despair of God's mercy, nor continue in sin, since baptism is a seal and undoubted testimony, that we have an eternal covenant of grace with God.


The Thanksgiving after baptism:


Almighty God and merciful Father, we thank and praise thee, that Thou hast forgiven us, and our children, all our sins, through the blood of thy beloved Son Jesus Christ, and received us through thy Holy Spirit as members of thine only begotten Son, and adopted us to be thy children, and sealed and confirmed the same unto us by holy baptism; we beseech thee, through the same Son of thy love, that Thou wilt be pleased always to govern these baptized children by thy Holy Spirit, that they may be piously and religiously educated, increase and grow up in the Lord Jesus Christ, that they may then acknowledge thy fatherly goodness and mercy, which Thou hast shown to them and us, and live in all righteousness, under our only Teacher, King and High Priest, Jesus Christ; and manfully fight against, and overcome sin, the devil and his whole dominion, to the end that they may eternally praise and magnify thee, and thy Son Jesus Christ, together with the Holy Ghost, the one only true God. Amen.


The prayer refers only to the elect; we cannot presuppose that it is for all.


2. The teaching that the promise of the covenant is an objective bequest on the part of God giving to every baptized child the right to Christ and all the blessings of salvation.


B. And we maintain:


1. That God surely and infallibly fulfills His promise to the elect.


2. The sure promise of God which He realizes in us as rational and moral creatures not only makes it impossible that we should not bring forth fruits of thankfulness but also confronts us with the obligation of love, to walk in a new and holy life, and constantly to watch unto prayer.


All those who are not thus disposed, who do not repent but walk in sin, are the objects of His just wrath and excluded from the kingdom of heaven.


That the preaching comes to all; and that God seriously commands to faith and repentance, and that to all those who come and believe He promises life and peace.


Grounds:


a. The Baptism Form, part 3.


b. The Form for the Lord's Supper, under "thirdly":


All those, then, who are thus disposed, God will certainly receive in mercy, and count them worthy partakers of the table of his Son Jesus Christ. On the contrary, those who do not feel this testimony in their hearts, eat and drink judgment to themselves.


Therefore, we also, according to the command of Christ and the Apostle Paul, admonish all those who are defiled with the following sins, to keep themselves from the table of the Lord, and declare to them that they have no part in the kingdom of Christ; such as all idolaters, all those who invoke deceased saints, angels, or other creatures; all those who worship images; all enchanters, diviners, charmers, and those who confide in such enchantments; all despisers of God, and of his Word, and of the holy sacraments; all blasphemers; all those who are given to raise discord, sects and mutiny in Church or State; all perjured persons; all those who are disobedient to their parents and superiors; all murders, contentious persons, and those who live in hatred and envy against their neighbors; all adulterers, whoremongers, drunkards, thieves, usurers, robbers, gamsters, covetous, and all who lead offensive lives.


All these, while they continue in such sins, shall abstain from this meat (which Christ hath ordained only for the faithful), lest their judgment and condemnation be made the heavier.


c. The Heidelberg Catechism XXIV, 64; XXXI, 84; XLV, 116:


Q. 64. But doth not this doctrine make men careless and profane?


A. By no means: for it is impossible that those, who are implanted into Christ by a true faith, should not bring forth fruits of thankfulness.


Q. 84. How is the kingdom of heaven opened and shut by the preaching of the holy gospel?


A. Thus: when according to the command of Christ, it is declared and publicly testified to all and every believer, that, whenever they receive the promise of the gospel by a true faith, all their sins are really forgiven them of God, for the sake of Christ's merits; and on the contrary, when it is declared and testified to all unbelievers, and such as do not sincerely repent, that they stand exposed to the wrath of God, and eternal condemnation, so long as they are unconverted: according to which testimony of the Gospel, God will judge them, both in this, and in the life to come.


Q. 116. Why is prayer necessary for Christians?


A. Because it is the chief part of thankfulness which God requires of us: and also, because God will give his grace and Holy Spirit to those only, who with sincere desires continually ask them of him, and are thankful for them.


Canons III-IV, A, 12, 16, 17:


Art. 12. And this is the regeneration so highly celebrated in Scripture, and denominated a new creation: a resurrection from the dead, a making alive, which God works in us without our aid. But this is in no wise effected merely by the external preaching of the gospel, by moral suasion, or such a mode of operation, that after God has performed his part, it still remains in the power of man to be regenerated or not, to be converted, or to continue unconverted; but it is evidently a supernatural work, most powerful, and at the same time most delightful, astonishing, mysterious, and ineffable; not inferior in efficacy to creation, or the resurrection from the dead, as the Scripture inspired by the author of this work declares; so that all in whose heart God works in this marvelous manner, are certainly, infallibly, and effectually regenerated, and do actually believe. Whereupon the will thus renewed, is not only actuated and influenced by God, but in consequence of this influence, becomes itself active. Wherefore also, man is himself rightly said to believe and repent, by virtue of that grace received.


Art 16. But as man by the fall did not cease to be a creature, endowed with understanding and will, nor did sin which pervaded the whole race of mankind, deprive him of the human nature, but brought upon him depravity and spiritual death; so also this grace of regeneration does not treat men as senseless stocks and blocks, nor takes away their will and its properties, neither does violence thereto; but spiritually quickens, heals, corrects, and at the same time sweetly and powerfully bends it; that where carnal rebellion and resistance formerly prevailed, a ready and sincere spiritual obedience begins to reign; in which the true and spiritual restoration and freedom of our will consist. Wherefore unless the admirable author of every good work wrought in us, man could have no hope of recovering from his fall by his own free will, by the abuse of which, in a state of innocence, he plunged himself into ruin.


Art. 17. As the almighty operation of God, whereby he prolongs and supports this our natural life, does not exclude, but requires the use of means, by which God of his infinite mercy and goodness hath chosen to exert his influence, so also the before mentioned supernatural operation of God, by which we are regenerated, in no wise excludes, or subverts the use of the gospel, which the most wise God has ordained to be the seed of regeneration, and food of the soul. Wherefore, as the apostles, and teachers who succeeded them, piously instructed the people concerning this grace of God, to his glory, and the abasement of all pride, and in the meantime, however, neglected not to keep them by the sacred precepts of the gospel in the exercise of the Word, sacraments and discipline; so even to this day, be it far from either instructors or instructed to presume to tempt God in the church by separating what he of his good pleasure hath most intimately joined together. For grace is conferred by means of admonitions; and the more readily we perform our duty, the more eminent usually is this blessing of God working in us, and the more directly is his work advanced; to whom alone all the glory both of means, and of their saving fruit and efficacy is forever due. Amen.


Canons III-IV, B, 9:


Art. 9. Who teach: that grace and free will are partial causes, which together work the beginning of conversion, and that grace, in order of working, does not precede the working of the will; that is, that God does not efficiently help the will of man unto conversion until the will of man moves and determines to do this. For the ancient Church has long ago condemned this doctrine of the Pelagians according to the words of the Apostle: "So then it is not of him that willeth, nor of him that runneth, but of God that hath mercy," Romans 9:16. Likewise: "For who maketh thee to differ? and what hast thou that thou didst not receive?" I Corinthians 4:7. And: "For it is God who worketh in you both to will and to work, for his good pleasure," Phillippians 2:13.


Canons V, A, 14:


Art. 14. And as it hath pleased God, by the preaching of the gospel, to begin this work of grace in us, so he preserves, continues, and perfect it by the hearing and reading of his Word, by meditation thereon, and by the exhortations, threatenings, and promises thereof, as well as by the use of the sacraments.


Netherlands Confession, Article XXIV:


Art. XXIV. We believe that this true faith being wrought in man by the hearing of the Word of God, and the operation of the Holy Ghost, doth regenerate and make him a new man, causing him to live a new life, and freeing him from the bondage of sin. Therefore it is so far from being true, that this justifying faith makes men remiss in a pious and holy life, that on the contrary without it they would never do anything out of love to God, but only out of self-love or fear of damnation. Therefore it is impossible that this holy faith can be unfruitful in man: for we do not speak of a vain faith, but of such a faith, which is called in Scripture, a faith that worketh by love, which excites man to the practice of those works, which God has commanded in his Word.


Which works, as they proceed from the good root of faith, are good and acceptable in the sight of God, forasmuch as they are all sanctified by His grace: howbeit they are of no account towards our justification. For it is by faith in Christ that we are justified, even before we do good works; otherwise they could not be good works, any more than the fruit of a tree can be good, before the tree itself is good.


Therefore we do good works, but not to merit by them, (for what can we merit?) nay, we are beholden to God for the good works we do, and not he to us, since it is he that worketh in us both to will and to do of his good pleasure. Let us therefore attend to what is written: when ye shall have done all those things which are commanded you, say, we are unprofitable servants; we have done that which was our duty to do. In the meantime, we do not deny that God rewards our good works, but it is through his grace that he crowns his gifts.


Moreover, though we do good works, we do not found our salvation upon them; for we do no work but what is polluted by our flesh, and also punishable; and although we could perform such works, still the remembrance of one sin is sufficient to make God reject them. thus then we would always be in doubt, tossed to and fro without any certainty, and our poor consciences continually vexed, if they relied not on the merits of the suffering and death of our Savior.


3. That the ground of infant baptism is the command of God and the fact that according to Scripture He established His covenant in the line of continued generations.


IV. Besides, the Protestant Reformed Churches:

Believe and maintain the autonomy of the local church.


For proof we refer to the Netherlands Confession, Article XXXI:


Art. XXXI. We believe, that the ministers of God's Word, and the elders and deacons, ought to be chosen to their respective offices by a lawful election by the Church, with calling upon the name of the Lord, and in that order which the Word of God teacheth. Therefore every one must take heed, not to intrude himself by indecent means, but is bound to wait till it shall please God to call him; that he may have testimony of his calling, and be certain and assured that it is of the Lord. As for the ministers of God's Word, they have equally the same power and authority wheresoever they are, as they are all ministers of Christ, the only universal Bishop, and the only Head of the Church. Moreover, that this holy ordinance of God may not be violated or slighted, we say that every one ought to esteem the ministers of God's Word, and the elders of the church, very highly for their work's sake, and be at peace with them without murmuring, strife or contention, as much as possible.


Church Order, Article 36:


Art. 36. The classis has the same jurisdiction over the consistory as the particular synod has over the classis and the general synod over the particular.


Only the consistory has authority over the local congregation. Church Order, Article 84.


Art. 84. No church shall in any way lord it over other churches, no minister over other ministers, no elder or deacon over other elders or deacons.


The Form for the Installation of Elders and Deacons:


"...called of God's Church, and consequently of God himself...."

Friday, January 24, 2025

The Free Offer of the Gospel, Common Grace, and Pragmatic Church Growth: Conclusion

 

For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; to the Jew first, and also to the Greek. 17 For therein is the righteousness of God revealed from faith to faith: as it is written, The just shall live by faith. (Romans 1:16-17 KJV)

“ . . . In classical Greek pornos frequently, even usually, refers to homosexuals.  Other passages, . . . very explicitly condemn homosexuals.  For many years, even centuries, the Church has had little cause to apply these prohibitions in cases of discipline, for there was little or no such sin within the Church, but now, in the end of the twentieth century, the apostate denominations are not only condoning unnatural vice, they even form homosexual congregations.”  Dr. Gordon H. Clark

 

The Free Offer of the Gospel, Common Grace, and Pragmatic Church Growth:  Conclusion

 

I grew up in a different time in the early 1960’s, 70’s and 80’s.  As a baby boomer, I lived through the time of the invention of the color television set, the personal computer, the internet, and the evolution of the modern cellphone.  The technological advances have been enormous.  The internet and computer Bible software have greatly enhanced the spread of information about theology, biblical studies, apologetics, and a host of other sources of information about the Christian worldview.  Unfortunately, the dark side of technological advancement is the applications of those technologies for disinformation, misinformation, and outright propaganda.  In my view, this undermines the doctrine of common grace because instead of advancing the kingdom of God on earth it has instead promoted compromise, shallowness, and misusing proselytization as a form of evangelism. 

Simply getting new members to join a church is not the same thing as the command given by Jesus in Matthew 28:18-20.  The imperative given there is to go into the world to all nations and to make disciples, baptizing them in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit.  But does the church growth movement do that?  I am not the first to answer that question in the negative.  Church has become more about appeasing sinners than speaking the truth.  Church has become more about pleasing seekers with good entertainment than about worshipping God or hearing the unadulterated word of God preached.  Instead of putting God first and the people of God first, the pragmatists have undermined solid biblical teaching and book by book expository preaching to replace it with meeting the emotional, psychological, and felt needs of the unbelievers. This approach has even descended to the level of giving homosexuals a special status.  All sin is sinful and there is nothing special about sexual immorality, especially a sexual immorality that violates basic biological nature.  God created humanity as male and female.  Genesis 1:27.  Furthermore, God made Adam head over his wife, Eve.  Patriarchy troubles modern egalitarians, but this is what the Bible says. 

God is not literally a man, yet the Bible always addresses God by masculine titles.  God is our Father, and His Son is our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ.  The Holy Spirit is not presented by male titles, yet the pronouns used of the Holy Spirit are always masculine, not neuter.  (John 16:7; John 14:16; John 14:26.  See also:  Got Questions:  Is the Holy Spirit a “He,” “She,” or “It,” male, female, or neuter?).

The Apostle Paul makes it perfectly clear that Christians are to shun those who refuse to walk in faith and who are caught up in sexual immorality:

6 Your glorying is not good. Do you not know that a little leaven leavens the whole lump? 7 Therefore purge out the old leaven, that you may be a new lump, since you truly are unleavened. For indeed Christ, our Passover, was sacrificed for us. (1 Corinthians 5:6-7 NKJV).

I wrote to you in my epistle not to keep company with sexually immoral people. 10 Yet I certainly did not mean with the sexually immoral people of this world, or with the covetous, or extortioners, or idolaters, since then you would need to go out of the world. 11 But now I have written to you not to keep company with anyone named a brother, who is sexually immoral, or covetous, or an idolater, or a reviler, or a drunkard, or an extortioner-- not even to eat with such a person. (1 Corinthians 5:9-11 NKJV).

You ran well. Who hindered you from obeying the truth? 8 This persuasion does not come from Him who calls you. 9 A little leaven leavens the whole lump. 10 I have confidence in you, in the Lord, that you will have no other mind; but he who troubles you shall bear his judgment, whoever he is. (Galatians 5:7-10 NKJV).

Moreover, this includes both those outside the church and those who are members of the visible church.  Although it is true that the Presbyterians are not naïve about whether or not a person who makes a profession of faith is truly regenerate or not, they do require that the person makes a public profession of faith before being baptized and joining the church.  In regards to children who were baptized in infancy, they must be catechized using the Westminster Shorter Catechism, and they must make a valid profession of faith and be confirmed before partaking of the Lord’s table.  Some Presbyterians have taken this to the extreme by taking a Lutheran view of the sacraments of baptism and the Lord’s supper.  But anyone familiar with church history can see that John Calvin reached a consensus with the Zwinglians on the sacraments called the Consensus of Tigurinus.  Calvin and the Zwinglians were in agreement in rejecting any sacerdotal powers in the waters of baptism or any real presence in the sacramental elements of bread and wine.  Instead, the true power of the sacraments was in being truly regenerate, having a genuine faith, and resting in the Gospel message of the word preached along with the sacrament.  Thus, it was more than just becoming a member of the church and partaking of the sacraments as some sort of magical real presence of Christ in the bread and wine.  Archbishop Thomas Cranmer, the father of the English Reformation, also took a Zwinglian and Calvinist view of the sacraments.  His treatise on the Lord’s supper plainly says that the bread and wine are called by the names that they represent and that eating the tangible elements is a metaphorical and spiritual eating and drinking of the body and blood of Christ.  Only a true believer can partake of the body and blood of Christ because faith is the necessary element that makes a person worthy to partake of the consecrated bread and wine:

WCF 29.8  Although ignorant and wicked men receive the outward elements in this sacrament; yet, they receive not the thing signified thereby; but, by their unworthy coming thereunto, are guilty of the body and blood of the Lord, to their own damnation. Wherefore, all ignorant and ungodly persons, as they are unfit to enjoy communion with Him, so are they unworthy of the Lord's table and cannot, without great sin against Christ, while they remain such, partake of these holy mysteries, or be admitted thereunto. (Westminster Confession of Faith.  Westminster Standards.)

In the same way, in order to become a member of the visible church, one must be more than a seeker who is looking for something.  In fact, the Bible says that there is no such thing as a “seeker”.

As it is written: “There is none righteous, no, not one; 11 There is none who understands; There is none who seeks after God. 12 They have all turned aside; They have together become unprofitable; There is none who does good, no, not one.” 13 “Their throat is an open tomb; With their tongues they have practiced deceit”; “The poison of asps is under their lips”; 14 “Whose mouth is full of cursing and bitterness.” 15 “Their feet are swift to shed blood; 16 Destruction and misery are in their ways; 17 And the way of peace they have not known.” 18 “There is no fear of God before their eyes.” 19 Now we know that whatever the law says, it says to those who are under the law, that every mouth may be stopped, and all the world may become guilty before God. 20 Therefore by the deeds of the law no flesh will be justified in His sight, for by the law is the knowledge of sin. (Romans 3:10-20 NKJV)

 . . . for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, (Romans 3:23 NKJV)

The pragmatic church growth movement turns the moral law and the Gospel on its head.  Instead of calling for repentance and faith, the pragmatists seek to appease unbelievers and entertain them with hypnotic contemporary praise and worship music which they have adopted from the Pentecostal/Charismatic style of worship.  There is a watered-down liturgy where a weak confession of sin is read and then a very weak corporate pronouncement of absolution.  The absolution is supposed to be a Gospel absolution, not a sacerdotal pronouncement of forgiveness as a power given to a priest or presbyter.  Of course, the church does possess the keys to the kingdom, but those keys are the preaching of the Word or Gospel message of the Bible and the right administration of the two Gospel sacraments:

1 The Lord Jesus, as King and Head of His Church, hath therein appointed government, in the hand of Church officers, distinct from the civil magistrate. 2 To these officers the keys of the kingdom of heaven are committed, by virtue whereof, they have power, respectively, to retain, and remit sins; to shut that kingdom against the impenitent, both by the Word, and censures; and to open it unto penitent sinners, by the ministry of the Gospel; and by absolution from censures, as occasion shall require. 3 Church censures are necessary, for the reclaiming and gaining of offending brethren, for deterring of others from the like offences, for purging out of that leaven which might infect the whole lump, for vindicating the honour of Christ, and the holy profession of the Gospel, and for preventing the wrath of God, which might justly fall upon the Church, if they should suffer His covenant, and the seals thereof, to be profaned by notorious and obstinate offenders. 4 For the better attaining of these ends, the officers of the Church are to proceed by admonition; suspension from the sacrament of the Lord’s Supper for a season; and by excommunication from the Church; according to the nature of the crime, and demerit of the person. (WCF 30:1-4, Westminster Confessional Standards).

According to the modern church growth model, seekers should be the emphasis, not the edification of the church as a whole.  Anyone who questions the shallowness of the preaching or the ameliorated preaching of the moral law is seen as a troublemaker and a disturber of the peace of the church. 

The Revoice movement, following the church growth pragmatic principle, seeks to downplay homosexuality so that “celibate” homosexuals can join the church while still “identifying” as “gay” or “lesbian” Christians.  This is allowing wickedness and immorality into the church.  As I said in an earlier blog post, a minister preached a fairly good sermon against wokeness just prior to the November general elections.  Then in the middle of the sermon he invited homosexuals to the church and said that they are welcome there.  Would he make the same offer to current adulterers or fornicators?  “If you’re here and you’re a whoremonger or an adulterer, you’re welcome in this church.”  (See: Hebrews 13:4 KJV).  I think not.  I strongly object to the Tim Keller and Gospel Coalition approach to evangelism.  I would go so far as to say that Tim Keller was a reprobate, not a true believer.  Those who follow Tim Keller’s church growth pragmatics do not deserve the name of Christian or even Presbyterian.  They are enemies of Christ.  Any church or denomination following that model is not planting churches.  They are planting apostasy and unbelief by accommodating to the culture of homosexuality, compromise, and concession to the enemy.

The church growth movement recommends reaching out to select groups of people of one cultural group or class.  So, most church plants are directed toward suburban middle class white people.  The reason for this is obvious.  First, they have good jobs and financial security; they are able to contribute to the financial needs of the church.  This undermines the Gospel because it makes the end goal the successful planting of a financially self-sustaining church.  Furthermore, the end justifies the means.  The church planter is using utilitarian ethics to accomplish a goal.  As I said in an earlier post, parachurch ministries and even church plants were focused on homosexuals, the end result of which was disappointing.  Instead of producing a church of true converts, the result was a church full of outwardly repentant and celibate homosexuals who still identified as homosexuals instead of moving on, getting married to the opposite sex, and having a family.  Even the pastor whom I wrote said that he did not expect the homosexual to actually be attracted to the opposite sex or get married.  But the Apostle Paul expected young widows to remarry instead of being busy bodies and gossipers making trouble in the church.  Only those with the gift of celibacy should remain single, according to Paul.  (See 1 Corinthians 7:1-9; 1 Timothy 5:11-15).

One Arminian based parachurch ministry located in Orlando, Florida dissolved the ministry after its president and leadership, all former homosexuals, recanted their conversion to Christ and went back to living in their immoral and perverse homosexual lifestyle.  (See:  Exodus International:  Religion News: Ex-gay group Exodus International shuts down, president apologizes).  The efforts to cause reprobates to believe the Gospel and be converted using worldly psychology and conversion therapy does not work.  The Bible says that it is God who converts the sinner, not persuasion or secular science pretending to be “Christian”.  It is the power of the Gospel message as it is enabled by the Holy Spirit which brings about the effectual call and repentance.  Only God can bring an elect sinner to the point of conversion.  Even here, the sinner is passive in regeneration and in the perseverance of the faith which results from regeneration.   (John 3:3-8; Jude 1:24-25; 2 Timothy 1:12; 1 Corinthians 1:8). 

I therefore oppose all business and corporate models for church planting.  My approach, should I ever plant a church, would be to preach the Gospel without fear of man’s opinions.  We are to please God, not man.  If it be God’s will, then the church plant will succeed without compromising the moral law or the Gospel.  (See: Galatians 1:6-10 NKJV; Acts 5:34-39 NKJV). 

I will close here with the full quote from Dr. Gordon H. Clark’s commentary on 1 Corinthians 5:8-13:

Although the case under discussion was one of incest [1 Corinthians 5:1-5], Paul uses the term “fornicators” (pornois).  Of course, incest is a kind of fornication, since a biblical marriage cannot there exist.  However, in classical Greek pornos frequently, even unusally, refers to homosexuals.  Other passages, for example, Romans 1:24, 26-27, very explicitly condemn homosexuals.  For many years, even centuries, the Church has had little cause to apply these prohibitions in cases of discipline, for there was little or no such sin within the Church, but now, in the end of the twentieth century, the apostate denominations are not only condoning unnatural vice, they even form homosexual congregations.  If these denominations were not apostate, if they were Christian, they would preach hell fire and warn these dregs of depraved humanity that against them the wrath of God is revealed from heaven, and perhaps by God’s grace induce them to cleanse their filth by the blood of Christ.

. . . In one’s everyday business, it is impossible to avoid all such associations.  . . . The command in 1 Corinthians, on the contrary, forbids the Church to have fornicators, homosexuals, incestuous persons in its membership.  The command also covers other sinners:  thieves and idolators.  Hodge remarks that this is the earliest known instance of the use of the word eidololatres.  Liddell and Scott give no earlier instance.

Dr. Gordon H. Clark.  First Corinthians. 1975.  Second edition.  (Jefferson:  Trinity Foundation, 1991). P. 84.

What changed?  What has changed is that theological liberalism and apostasy has taken over many, if not most, of the supposedly Evangelical churches, denominations, colleges and seminaries.  If we do not take a bold stance against apostasy, there could be only a small remnant of true churches left.  May God have mercy on us.

See previous posts here:  Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, Part 5.

Sunday, January 19, 2025

The Free Offer of the Gospel, Common Grace, and Pragmatic Church Growth: Part 5

 

  

“. . . The trouble with Arminianism is that it is illogical.  It retains parts of the Biblical message, but because of its unscriptural theory of free will rejects other parts.” 

Dr. Gordon H. Clark.  What Do Presbyterians Believe?  The Westminster Confession Yesterday and Today.  (Unicoi:  Trinity Foundation, 2001), p. 174.

 

For as the Father raises the dead and gives life to them, even so the Son gives life to whom He will. (Jn. 5:21 NKJV)

 

 

The Free Offer of the Gospel, Common Grace, and Pragmatic Church Growth:  Part 5

 

In a recent podcast, Tucker Carlson, a former news anchor at Fox News who is now an independent political pundit, made the point that in this technological era citizens of the United States of America are treated as commodities to be manipulated by government propaganda and leftist news organizations which work behind the scenes to manipulate the information given to the populace.  Another former reporter, Megan Basham, has exposed the fact that leftist news organizations are also working behind the scenes with Evangelical church denominations, Evangelical colleges and seminaries, and the church growth movement to change the Evangelical message from its commitment to biblical truth to an agenda of this worldly social justice called wokeism or Marxism.

The most prominent church growth advocate in Reformed circles was the late Dr. Tim Keller.  Keller’s views were openly in favor of theistic evolution, Biologos, LGBTQIA+ outreach, social justice, and other accommodations to the Marxist culture of the political left in our nation.  The argument given for doing this is that in order to reach the unchurched in our nation, we must reach them where they are.  The underlying basis for this argument was the unscriptural foundation of common grace, the free offer of the Gospel, the well meant offer, and pragmatic methods of evangelism.

As much as I do not like to appeal to my personal experience, I am old enough to remember a time before megachurches, the internet, artificial intelligence, and the church growth movement.  As a former Pentecostal of the 1980s era, I can recall that Pentecostals and Charismatics were somewhat conflicted over whether the Charismatic movement was a good thing or something bad.  But both sides boasted of the phenomenal growth of the Pentecostal/Charismatic movement worldwide.  The oft repeated appeal of the movement was the explosive growth of the Pentecostal/Charismatic movement in the global south, Africa, and Latin America.  Many of these countries were and are considered third world countries where many of the superstitions of the past continue in the popular culture.  So, the ground was ripe for the psychological manipulation of huge crowds at mass evangelistic campaigns organized by Charismatic preachers who taught the health and wealth gospel.  There was a huge response because the most of the people living in these countries were susceptible to being manipulated because of their extreme poverty and because of health and medical issues and the lack of access to modern healthcare facilities.

The supposed success of the church growth movement as it was adopted and promoted by Charismatics like C. Peter Wagner and Charles Kraft, was soon adopted by formerly holiness Pentecostal churches from the more classical background of the Wesley holiness and entire sanctification theology of the holiness movement of the 19th century.  In a previous post, I mentioned that I was converted at about age 8 or 9 at a Pentecostal Church of God, (which is headquartered in Cleveland, Tennessee), located in Weaver, Alabama.  That church was thoroughly old school and classical Pentecostal with a hard focus on Christian holiness and holy living.  The minister literally scared the hell out of me that day because he was preaching a fire and brimstone message.  In modern times this kind of preaching is few and far between among Church of God Pentecostal churches, Pentecostal holiness churches, or even Assemblies of God churches.  Most of the Pentecostal movement has moved on from the holiness movement and has adopted a more Charismatic approach to evangelistic preaching.

The popularity of the church growth principles spread to other denominations afterwards, but without the emphasis on the charismatic gifts of the Holy Spirit or the Pentecostal emphasis on entire sanctification and the empowerment for evangelistic and supernatural service.  (See Acts 1:8; Acts 2:1-4).  Southern Baptists like Rick Warren became widely popular and successful in building megachurches.  Joel Osteen de-emphasized his charismatic theology by transforming the Word of Faith doctrine into a positive thinking ministry much like the late Norman Vincent Peale’s ministry.  Osteen’s church in Houston is supposed the largest megachurch in the United States.

Methodists, Evangelical Free, Lutherans, and Presbyterians all happily jumped on the megachurch pragmatic growth bandwagon because results matter.  However, the end result was not discipleship and a growth in spiritual discipline as promised.  Instead, what ended up happening was a multitude of churches full of apparently baby Christians or blatantly unconverted sinners who just wanted to be part of the entertainment and who wanted their unfelt needs met.  The emphasis of church plants was to downplay theological differences by removing the denominational affiliation from the church sign, having superficial contemporary praise and worship songs, emulating the Charismatics who denigrated denominational divides as well.  The approach of the Charismatics was to attack denominationalism as Pharisaical and legalistic Christianity.

The same approach has been taken by the common grace Presbyterians.  They constantly attack classical Presbyterians and classical Calvinists of the Dutch Reformed variety as legalistic Pharisees, hyper-Calvinists, and navel gazers who are focused only on themselves.  Tim Keller employed this tactic many times in his videos.  Keller formulated his own catechism called the New City Catechism where he downplayed the Calvinist distinctives, the Reformed confessional standards, and the doctrines of sovereign grace like the effectual call, unconditional election and special providence.  Instead, Keller preached like an Arminian using the appeal of the doctrine of common grace, which said that God loves everyone, including the reprobate, but only gave special saving grace to the elect.  In his actual preaching, however, Keller never mentions the difference between special grace and common grace.  He only emphasized common grace while the doctrines of sovereign grace faded into the background.  I should also mention that Keller’s catechism is not part of any reformed doctrinal standard.  The Three Points of Common Grace of 1924 are not the official doctrine of any modern Reformed denomination except the Christian Reformed Church, although most of the Reformed churches act as if common grace is official doctrine.

Keller used common grace as well to justify moving his focus from personal conversion to a more group oriented theology of social justice, theistic evolution, and forging pragmatic Christian community over and above Gospel focused evangelism.  Another compromise made by Keller was to stop focusing on sanctification as a process and instead to preach only justification by faith alone.  The Westminster standards, in contrast, focused on a preaching of the three uses of the moral law of God and then preaching the Gospel.  The pedagogical use of the moral law was supposed to show the sinner that he or she was lost and without any hope of keeping God’s law perfectly or of meriting or earning any forgiveness for their sins.  Of course, Keller did mention this pedagogical use of the law at times in order to emphasize justification by faith alone.  But because sanctification was not emphasized, Keller’s view, much like the Escondido, California version of Westminster theology, was much more closely related to a once saved always saved Baptist version of the doctrine of the perseverance of the saints.

The Presbyterian denominations today by and large do not preach the holiness of God or that the assurance of salvation can be lost without any change in the habits of the converted believer.  The one exception would be the Ligonier Ministries, but even here the doctrines of the free offer of the Gospel and common grace prevails.  The free offer teaches that God desires to save everyone but has not decreed to save everyone head for head.  This is a blatantly contradictory proposition.  If God truly desired or wished to save everyone, then surely God would have decreed to save everyone head for head; He would have unconditionally elected everyone;  He would have given everyone special saving grace or the effectual call.  In other words, common grace and the doctrine of the well meant offer or free offer of the Gospel teaches that God’s will is twofold.  In one aspect, God is powerless to save anyone, just like the Arminians!  In the other aspect, God’s will is not frustrated, and He saves those whom He has predetermined in eternity to save.  This is violation of the law of contradiction.  In other words, just as I cannot both go to lunch and not got to lunch.  Obviously, if God is Almighty and can do whatever He pleases, then whatever God has decreed to come to pass is what God desires and wills to do.  God has only one will.  The command to repent and believe the Gospel is the prescriptive will of God, not an emotional appeal based on some fake offer of salvation to those who are predestined to reprobation.

When the Scriptures say that God does not desire that anyone should perish, those passages are always directed either to the Old Testament congregation or nation of Israel or to the New Testament church.  None of those passages are directed to the pagan nations or to anyone outside of the church.  (See: 2 Peter 3:21 NKJV, and Ezekiel 33:11).  Even then, God does desire that some of the Israelites would perish:

". . .indeed, therefore, I will stretch out My hand against you, and give you as plunder to the nations; I will cut you off from the peoples, and I will cause you to perish from the countries; I will destroy you, and you shall know that I am the LORD." (Ezekiel 25:7 NKJV).

The warning passages apply to everyone without exception, yet on the elect are preserved from apostasy by God.  (See Romans 11).  Those of us who oppose common grace and the free offer are not hyper-Calvinists.  Even the Prostestant Reformed Churches in America advocate for the promiscuous preaching of the general call of the Gospel to everyone without exception.  This is not hyper-Calvinism at all.  The difference is between what doctrines are taught and emphasized.  Classical Calvinism teaches that God hates the wicked and the reprobate, not that God loves everyone in general, but that He has a special love for the elect.  In fact, in providential time on earth, even the elect are under God’s wrath temporarily until they are effectually called, though God does love them from all eternity.  (See Romans 9:11-13).

The LORD has appeared of old to me, saying: "Yes, I have loved you with an everlasting love; Therefore with lovingkindness I have drawn you. (Jeremiah 31:3 NKJV).

In his commentary on Westminster Confession of Faith, Dr. Gordon H. Clark says:

Someone may be tempted to say that although God undoubtedly calls the elect, he does not call them only, as the Confession says.  Does not God call everybody?  The answer to this question is to be found by searching the Scriptures.  John 12:39, 40 says, “They could not believe, because Esaias said again, He hath blinded their eyes and hardened their heart, that they should not see with their eyes nor understand with their heart, and be converted, and I should heal them.”  In Romans 11:7 we read, “Israel hath not obtained that which he seeketh for; but the election hath obtained it, and the rest were blinded.”  Since God does all that he pleases (Psalm 135:6), and since his causative power is omnipotent, it follows that he has not called the lost, but the elect only.

Of course, ministers and evangelists call people too.  That is, they preach the Gospel publicly.  But the effective call, the call that actually produces the proper response, comes from God alone.

Clark.  What Do Presbyterians Believe?, p. 114.

Only by rejecting biblical logic, biblical and propositional revelation, can anyone preach Arminianism and the compromises of the neo-reformed churches.  Are some of these people truly converted and effectually called by God?  Certainly some of them can be.  I myself was converted under Pentecostal holiness preaching in the mid 1960s.  But should we be compromising with Arminianism or the church growth movement?  I don’t think so.  In fact, many of the megachurches today have little to no difference with outright theological liberalism and leftist immorality.  Tim Keller’s evangelism is a good example of that.  He openly promoted the idea that homosexuals cannot be changed by God and that we should just accept them as celibate Christians.  But the Bible says that celibacy is a gift of God, not a moral imperative given to immutable homosexuals.

I could go on.  However, I will take a break here and continue this series in Part 6. 

You can read my previous posts on The Free Offer of the Gospel, Common Grace, and Pragmatic Church Growth here:

Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4.  

See the conclusion here:  Conclusion.

Support Reasonable Christian Ministries with your generous donation.